Credit card churning: how it works, issuer bonus rules and the credit cost
Edited by Moe Ameen · Published
Credit card churning means opening cards to collect their sign-up bonuses, then closing them and doing it again. Issuers push back. Chase's terms for one card shut out anyone who got its bonus in the last 24 months. Discover's look back 48 months from the last bonus, Wells Fargo's 48 months from opening, and Citi's Strata Premier terms exclude anyone who ever had it. Every application is a hard inquiry, and every new card lowers your average account age.
Key takeaways
- Churning is opening cards for their sign-up bonuses, then closing or downgrading them and repeating.
- Issuers print limits in their offer terms: a 24- or 48-month lookback, or a lifetime bar once you've had the card.
- Chase's "5/24 rule" isn't in Chase's published terms. Experian calls it unofficial.
- Each application is a hard inquiry, counted by FICO for a year, and each new card lowers your average account age.
- Issuers can close accounts and take back rewards if they think you're gaming the program.
What is credit card churning?
Opening credit cards mainly to earn their sign-up bonuses, then closing or downgrading them and repeating the cycle with the next card.
Experian defines it as repeatedly opening credit cards to earn intro bonuses [10]. A churner applies, spends enough to earn the bonus, takes it, and moves on to the next card. A sign-up bonus asks you to spend a set amount in a set window. On the Chase Sapphire Preferred page we read, that was $5,000 in purchases in the first 3 months [1]. How these offers work is covered in our sign-up bonuses guide.
Few cardholders churn. In a CardRatings survey of 1,750 cardholders, run in June 2019, 40% knew what churning was, 11% said they did it, and 26% of those churners said it wasn't worth it [15]. The survey is several years old, so treat it as a rough picture.
What is a churner, and where do churners compare notes?
A churner is someone who opens cards for their bonuses on a planned cycle. Reddit's r/churning is one forum where churners discuss how they do it.
Plenty of people go looking for the "r/churning flowchart". Any chart or rule list you find there was put together by other cardholders, not by an issuer, and an issuer can change its terms without telling a forum. Read the terms on the card's own application page before you count on a rule. The table further down quotes five issuer pages as they read on November 19, 2026.
What rules do card issuers use to limit sign-up bonuses?
Most issuers exclude people who have the card now, and many add a lookback: 24 or 48 months from your last bonus or from opening, or ever having held it.
- Chase Freedom Unlimited: not available to current cardmembers, or to past cardmembers who got this card's bonus in the last 24 months [2].
- Chase Sapphire Preferred: no time window. The bonus "may not be available" if you held the card before or got its bonus, and Chase may consider how many cards you've opened and closed [1].
- Citi Strata Premier: no bonus if you have or ever had a Strata Premier or Citi Premier account. Citi may also weigh your history of opening, closing and using cards [3].
- Discover it: existing or past cardmembers may not be eligible if they got a new cardmember bonus on the card in the past 48 months [4].
- Wells Fargo Autograph Journey: you may not be eligible for bonus offers if you have the card or opened one in the last 48 months, even if it's now closed with a $0 balance [5].
You've probably heard of other rules. Bankrate reports that Chase generally turns down applicants who opened five or more cards in the past 24 months, the "5/24 rule", and it describes limits it says other issuers use on how often you can open their cards [11]. Experian calls 5/24 unofficial and says American Express may let you earn a card's intro bonus only once [10]. None of those appeared in the terms we read on the issuers' own pages, so treat them as reported practice, not published policy.
Does credit card churning hurt your credit score?
It can. Each application is a hard inquiry, each new card lowers your average account age, and closing cards can push up your utilization.
Start with inquiries. For most people, one more takes less than five points off their FICO Scores, and it stays on the report up to two years but only counts for one [7]. Experian says several applications add to the damage [10]. New credit as a whole makes up 10% of a FICO Score, and myFICO says opening several accounts in a short period represents greater risk [8].
Then there's account age. Length of credit history, 15% of the score, looks at the average age of your accounts [8], and every new card pulls that average down [10]. Utilization can move either way. A new card adds available credit, which can lower your utilization [10]; closing it takes that credit away and can push the ratio back up [9]. The CFPB says many experts recommend using less than 30% of your total limit [14].
Closing a card doesn't wipe out its history right away. FICO Scores generally count both open and closed accounts, and bureaus often drop closed accounts in good standing after about 10 years [9]. The scoring details are in hard inquiries and credit utilization.
What can go wrong when you churn credit cards?
The issuer can close the account and take rewards back. Annual fees, interest or spending you didn't need can also eat the bonus.
- The issuer may close your card, and you'll lose the rewards, if it thinks you're gaming its program, Experian says [10]. The CFPB says issuers can generally close an account without notice [13].
- An issuer can also take back rewards it already paid [10].
- The bonus can fall through on fine print. Nearly one in ten dollars of rewards comes from sign-up bonuses, the CFPB says, and consumers told it the fine print didn't always match the marketing [12].
- Buying things you didn't need to hit a spending requirement costs real money. Carrying a balance costs more, as how credit card interest works shows.
- A $95 annual fee comes back every year you keep the card open [1][6]. Our annual fees guide covers when fees are charged and refunded.
Are churning bonuses taxable?
Usually not when you had to spend to earn them, CardRatings says. A bonus paid just for opening an account, with no spending, is generally reported as income.
CardRatings says most rewards aren't taxable because you have to spend money to get them, and that a cash bonus with no spending attached should be reported as income [16]. It also says no-spend card bonuses are relatively rare [16]. That's CardRatings' reading, not an IRS ruling on your bonus. Ask a tax professional how your own rewards are treated.
Glisten check
What five issuer pages say about repeat bonuses, and what churning does to the numbers
| Issuer and card | Who the bonus terms exclude | Lookback | Other factors the issuer names |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chase Freedom Unlimited [2] | Current cardmembers; past cardmembers who got this card's bonus recently | 24 months since the last bonus | None stated |
| Chase Sapphire Preferred [1] | Anyone with the card open now; the bonus may not be available if you held it before or got its bonus | None stated | Number of cards you've opened and closed |
| Citi Strata Premier [3] | Anyone who has or had a Strata Premier or Citi Premier account | Ever | History of opening, closing and using cards |
| Discover it [4] | Existing or past cardmembers who got this card's bonus recently | 48 months since the last bonus | None stated |
| Wells Fargo Autograph Journey [5] | Anyone who has the card or opened one recently, even if it's closed | 48 months since opening | None stated |
We couldn't read the eligibility wording on American Express's or Bank of America's terms pages when we checked, so they aren't in the table. The table describes what issuers publish. It doesn't recommend any card.
| Card | Bonus offer | Spending required | Per month | Annual fee | Value per point or mile to cover one year's fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital One Venture [6] | 75,000 miles | $4,000 in 3 months | $1,333.33 | $95 | 0.127 cents |
| Chase Sapphire Preferred [1] | 75,000 points | $5,000 in 3 months | $1,666.67 | $95 | 0.127 cents |
A churner who keeps either card into its second year pays the fee a second time, $190 across both years, with no new bonus on the same card. Points and miles are worth whatever the issuer's redemption options make them, so check that before you count a bonus as covering anything.
| Before | After opening four new cards | |
|---|---|---|
| Accounts and ages | 3 cards: 10, 6 and 4 years | 7 cards: 10, 6, 4 years plus four at 0 |
| Average account age | 6.67 years | 2.86 years |
| Utilization on a $3,000 balance | 30% of $10,000 in limits | 20% if one new card adds $5,000 in limits; back to 30% once it's closed |
Four new cards cut this person's average account age by more than half overnight. The utilization gain from new limits lasts only while the cards stay open. Close them after the bonus, as churners usually do, and the ratio goes back to where it started.
Is this right for you?
Best for
- People who pay every card in full each month and already spend enough to meet a requirement without buying extra.
- Anyone who reads each issuer's terms and tracks every card's dates, fees and lookbacks.
Frequently asked questions
What happens if an issuer thinks I'm churning?
It can refuse the bonus under its offer terms, and Experian says issuers may close the card and take back rewards if they think you're gaming the program [10]. The CFPB says issuers can generally close an account without notice [13].
What is the Chase 5/24 rule?
Bankrate reports that Chase generally turns down applicants who opened five or more cards in the past 24 months [11]. Experian calls it unofficial [10], and it wasn't in the Chase terms we read.
How many points does a new card application cost?
For most people, one more hard inquiry takes less than five points off their FICO Scores, and FICO counts it for a year [7]. It can be more with few accounts or a short history [7].
Can I get the same card's bonus twice?
It depends on the issuer. Chase's Freedom Unlimited terms exclude anyone who got its bonus in the last 24 months and Discover's use a 48-month window, while Citi's Strata Premier terms exclude anyone who ever had the card [2][3][4].
Does closing a card after the bonus hurt my credit?
It can raise your utilization by removing available credit [9]. The closed account usually keeps counting toward your history while it stays on your report, often around 10 years if it was in good standing [9].
What is the r/churning flowchart?
Flowcharts posted on r/churning come from forum members, not from any issuer. Check any rule it lists against the terms on the card's own application page.
How we know this
On November 19, 2026 we read the bonus-eligibility terms on the card pages of Chase, Citi, Discover and Wells Fargo, and the offer and fee lines on Chase's and Capital One's pages. Credit effects come from myFICO's pages on inquiries, score factors and closing cards, and the CFPB. We checked general claims against Experian, Bankrate and CardRatings. Rules that issuers don't publish, like 5/24, are attributed to the site that reports them. Spending per month is the requirement divided by 3; fee break-even is the $95 fee divided by 75,000 points; average age is the plain average of account ages. We name issuers only to quote their own terms. Nothing here is a recommendation.
- Chase Sapphire Preferred: offer details, Chase. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Chase Freedom Unlimited: offer details, Chase. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Citi Strata Premier Card: offer terms, Citi. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Discover it Cash Back: offer terms, Discover. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Wells Fargo Autograph Journey Visa Card: terms, Wells Fargo. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Capital One Venture Rewards card, Capital One. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Credit checks and inquiries, myFICO. Checked November 19, 2026.
- What's in my FICO Scores?, myFICO. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Should you close a credit card?, myFICO. Checked November 19, 2026.
- What is credit card churning?, Experian. Checked November 19, 2026.
- What is credit card churning and how does it affect your credit score?, Bankrate. Checked November 19, 2026.
- CFPB report highlights consumer frustrations with credit card rewards programs (May 9, 2024), CFPB. Checked November 19, 2026.
- My card issuer closed my account without notice. Can they do that?, CFPB. Checked November 19, 2026.
- How do I get and keep a good credit score?, CFPB. Checked November 19, 2026.
- One quarter of credit card churners say practice isn't worth it, CardRatings survey reveals, CardRatings. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Are credit card rewards taxable? A guide to credit cards and taxes, CardRatings. Checked November 19, 2026.
- Churning, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School. Checked November 19, 2026.